An hour north of Milwaukee are three cheesemakers who just won awards for the best cheese in the USA

The 2015 United States Championship Cheese Contest was held at the State Fair Grounds in Milwaukee on March 17th-19th . Cheesemakers from around the country competed for “Best of Class” in everything from mild cheddar to butter to drinkable yogurt.  We took a day trip to these three isolated cheese factories to investigate.  Its a relaxing countryside drive – and when can you say you saw three of the best cheeses in the USA on a short road trip?.

Stop number one:

Baker Cheese Factory
N5279 Co Rd G, St. Cloud, Wisconsin

2015-03-26 18.40.30

This is a logical first stop on your trip as it is just about an hour north of Milwaukee. Plus, you can buy some string cheese to snack on as you make your way to the other two stops.   Now in their fourth generation of cheese making, Baker Cheese Factory has been making only mozzarella since the 1950s. In fact, their string cheese won “Best of Class” beating out all other string cheesemakers in the USA.  See string cheese results here:

Baker’s factory store is open Monday-Friday 9-5pm, Saturday 9-1pm.

2015-03-26 18.42.23

Stop No. 2:

LaClare Farms, W2994 Co Rd HH, Malone, Wisconsin

From Baker Cheese, it’s only about a ten mile drive to LaClare Farms.  Established in 1978, LaClare Farms took home “Best of Class” for their hard goats milk cheeseEvalon and 3rd place for their Martone, a surface ripened mixed milk cheese.   Their specialty is sheep’s and goat’s milk cheese, and if you are there between 4:30 to 6:30, you can watch the goats being milked in the milking station.

2015-03-26 21.04.59

Plan to stop for lunch, as it has a cafe and a chef that is a culinary school grad.  I had one of the best burgers in a long time, stuffed with LaClare’s cheese.   The cafe’ menu, which includes a kid’s menu, is here. A flyer also advertised many different “craft beer nights” throughout the year featuring different breweries.

stuffed burger

Evalon is a Gouda-like artisan cheese with a hint of Asiago

evalon aging cellar



Don’t leave without getting a hand-dipped ice cream cone.  Many of the ice creams are made with goat’s or sheep’s milk.  We sampled a fig flavor, and it was unusually delicious.

Stop No. 3,
Henning’s Cheese (bandaged cheddar-best of class)
20201 Point Creek Rd, Kiel

Hennings Cheese sign

From LaClare Farms, Henning’s cheese is an easy 17 miles down a country road.  This fourth generation family-owned cheese factory started in 1914.  Henning’s was awarded “Best of Class” for their bandaged cheddar which makes it the best medium cheddar made in the USA.  Also the Pico de Queso Cheese was named one of the best cheeses in the USA.   Click here for full results.

hennings award winning medium cheddar

Hennings award winning Pico de Queso

Henning’s factory store and cheese museum is open Monday-Friday 7-4pm and Saturday 8-noon.  In addition Henning’s has a couple of viewing windows where you can watch the cheese being made.

hennings cheese offerings

cheese museum and view into cheese factory

If you missed ice cream at LaClare, you can grab a Cedar Valley Ice Cream cone at Henning’s.   From Henning’s Cheese in Kiel, its an easy hour and fifteen minute drive back to the Milwaukee area.   Close enough that you can make this trip without a cooler.   Don’t forget the fresh cheese curds!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s